Search
Accountant in a suit analyzing financial statements with a calculator and laptop at a desk

What Is a Quality of Earnings Report?

A quality of earnings (QoE) report is an independent analysis of a business’s historical financial results. It tests whether the earnings a seller reports are accurate, whether they are likely to continue, and how much cash the business really produces. Buyers use it to decide what a company is worth, lenders use it to size risk, and sellers use it to prepare for a sale.

The idea is simple. The profit on a seller’s financial statements or in a confidential information memorandum (CIM) is only a starting point. A QoE report works from that number to an adjusted figure you can rely on when you set a price.

This guide explains what a QoE report is, what it covers, what it is not, why it matters, when you need one, how long it takes, and how to choose a provider.

What a QoE Report Is and Who Prepares It

A QoE report, sometimes called a QoE analysis or QoE review, is the core deliverable of financial due diligence on a business acquisition. A CPA or financial advisor reviews several years of financial statements plus the most recent months, then tests them against bank statements, tax returns and supporting records.

A QoE is a consulting engagement, not an attest service. The American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) has not set a required standard for its scope or format, so reports vary from one provider to the next. That is one reason it helps to understand what a good report includes before you hire anyone.

The report answers a few practical questions:

  • What are the true, normalized earnings of this business?
  • Are those earnings supported by cash in the bank?
  • Will they continue after the current owner leaves?
  • How much working capital does the business need to operate?
  • What risks should affect the price or the terms of the deal?

Many businesses that sell for less than $5 million do not have carefully maintained financial statements. Even well-kept books do not show whether earnings will repeat. A QoE report fills that gap.

What a Quality of Earnings Report Covers

Scope differs by provider, but a solid QoE for a small or mid-sized acquisition includes the following areas.

Adjusted EBITDA and Add-Backs

EBITDA stands for earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization. It is the starting measure for most deal pricing. A QoE report rebuilds it from the ground up and shows each change between reported and adjusted EBITDA.

Sellers and brokers often present their own add-backs, such as owner compensation above market, personal expenses run through the business, or one-time costs. Just because a seller calls something an add-back does not make it one. The QoE team asks for support on each item and either accepts it, reduces it or reverses it.

The adjustments in a QoE usually fall into these groups:

  • Management adjustments. The seller’s own add-backs, as shown in the CIM or the financial package.
  • Management adjustment reversals. Items from the seller’s list that the provider could not support.
  • Reclassification adjustments. Items that were recorded in the wrong place, such as interest income included in revenue.
  • Normalization adjustments. Revenue or expenses that are not part of normal operations and should be removed.
  • Pro-forma adjustments. Changes you can expect under new ownership, such as a market-rate salary for a replacement manager or a new supplier price.

Normalizing is easiest to see with an example. Suppose the owner pays 40% below market rent because the landlord is the owner’s brother. A buyer will not get that discount, so the QoE restates rent at fair market value and lowers EBITDA to match. The purpose is to show earnings as they would look under normal conditions with you as the owner.

Proof of Cash

A proof of cash reconciles the revenue and expenses on the books to the bank statements for the same periods. It shows whether the deposits and payments match what the seller reports. Differences can point to unrecorded sales, personal spending, loans that were treated as revenue, or plain bookkeeping errors. We cover the method in more detail in our guide to what a proof of cash is.

Net Working Capital and the Peg

Net working capital is current assets minus current liabilities. It is the money a business needs to run day to day. If the seller hands over a business with too little working capital, the buyer has to fund the shortfall after closing, which raises the real price.

A QoE report studies working capital month by month, removes unusual items, and proposes a normal level. That level becomes the working capital target, often called the peg, which can be written into the purchase agreement. Our articles on calculating net working capital and estimating working capital before the LOI walk through the math.

Revenue Quality

Not all revenue is equal. A QoE looks at where sales come from and how likely they are to continue. Common tests include:

  • Customer concentration. If one or two customers produce most of the revenue, losing one after closing can change the whole deal.
  • Supplier concentration. A single key supplier can raise prices or create supply problems.
  • Recurring versus one-time revenue. Repeat work is worth more than a large project that will not come again.
  • Trends by month. Seasonality, recent growth and recent declines are easier to see in monthly data.
  • Related-party dealings. Sales to or purchases from the seller’s family or other companies may not continue on the same terms.
  • Revenue recognition. Many small businesses keep their books on a cash basis, which can distort profit. A QoE restates results so revenue and expenses fall in the right period.

Debt-Like Items and Accounting Practices

The report also looks for obligations that act like debt but may not appear as debt on the balance sheet, such as unpaid taxes, customer deposits, deferred revenue or accrued bonuses. It reviews accounting policies for errors and compares the business to industry benchmarks where that data exists. If margins or ratios differ sharply from peers, the report explains why.

How to Read a Quality of Earnings Report

Layouts vary, but most reports can be read in the same order:

  1. Start with the summary. Most reports open with a short list of findings and the headline adjusted EBITDA figure.
  2. Follow the bridge. Look at the schedule that walks from reported earnings to adjusted EBITDA. Check that every add-back has a reason and support behind it.
  3. Compare to the CIM. Note where the provider’s number differs from the seller’s, and read the explanation for each difference.
  4. Check the run rate. Run rate performance projects current results forward and shows what the business is doing now, not only what it did in earlier years.
  5. Read the working capital section. Confirm the proposed peg makes sense for the seasonality of the business.
  6. Review the risk items. Customer concentration, debt-like items and unsupported figures should be reflected in your offer or your terms.

What a Quality of Earnings Report Is Not

Because the name sounds official, buyers sometimes expect more or less than a QoE delivers.

It Is Not an Audit

An audit is an attest service performed by a licensed CPA firm. It gives an opinion on whether financial statements follow generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP). A QoE is a consulting engagement with a different goal. It focuses on the sustainability of earnings, cash and working capital, which is what a buyer needs to set a price. Most small businesses are not audited, and a QoE does not replace an audit.

It Is Not a Forecast

A QoE is based on historical information. It can show a run rate and identify what supports earnings going forward, but it does not predict next year’s results. Projections require assumptions about growth, markets and management that sit outside the report.

It Is Not a Valuation

A QoE does not tell you what to pay. It gives you a reliable earnings figure, and a valuation then applies a multiple to that figure. Price still depends on the multiple, the terms, the risks and what the buyer is willing to accept.

It Is Not Tax or Legal Due Diligence

Tax exposure, contracts, licenses and legal disputes are separate workstreams handled by other advisors. A QoE may point to an area that needs a closer look, but it does not replace those reviews.

It Has Limits

Even a well-run QoE depends on the information provided. The report relies on historical records, the books may contain improper accounting, some information may not be available, and a provider can let bias affect the analysis. Good providers state their limits clearly.

Why a Quality of Earnings Report Matters

For Buyers

  • It protects the price. Small changes in EBITDA become large changes in value once a multiple is applied. A QoE helps you avoid paying for earnings that are not real.
  • It finds red flags early. Concentration, unsupported add-backs, accounting errors and cash that does not match the books are easier to deal with before closing than after.
  • It supports negotiation. Documented findings give you a factual basis to ask for a lower price, different terms or a working capital target.
  • It connects value to cash. It helps bridge enterprise value to the equity value you will actually receive, after debt-like items and working capital.
  • It helps after closing. The report shows how the business runs, which makes the first months of ownership easier.

For Sellers

A sell-side QoE puts the seller’s own adjustments in front of buyers with support already attached. It also lets the seller find and fix problems before a buyer does. Our article on sell-side quality of earnings explains how this works.

For Lenders

Lenders rely on QoE findings to confirm that cash flow can support the debt. For some SBA loans, a QoE is now required, as described below.

When Do You Need a Quality of Earnings Report?

You should consider a QoE in any of these cases:

  • You are buying a business and the price depends on earnings.
  • The seller’s financial statements are unaudited, on a cash basis, or kept by a bookkeeper rather than an accountant.
  • A lender, investor or partner wants independent confirmation of earnings.
  • You are selling and want buyers to trust your numbers.
  • The business has customer concentration, owner-dependent revenue or recent changes.

Under the Small Business Administration’s updated SOP 50 10 8.1, a QoE report is required for SBA 7(a) acquisitions with a purchase price of $3 million or more, for applications received on or after October 1, 2026. We explain the rule, the exemptions and who engages the provider in our article on the SBA quality of earnings requirement.

For more on why a QoE matters in smaller deals, see quality of earnings for SMB acquisitions.

How Long Does a Quality of Earnings Report Take, and What Does It Cost?

Most QoE engagements take 2 to 4 weeks, depending on how quickly the seller provides records and how complex the business is. Typical requests include several years of financial statements, tax returns, bank statements, payroll records, a revenue breakdown by customer and the seller’s list of add-backs.

Cost depends on the size and complexity of the business, the quality of its records, the industry and the scope of the work. At Midwest CPA, QoE work is done for a fixed fee, so you know the cost before the work begins. For a closer look at what moves the price, read what factors influence the cost of a quality of earnings report.

How to Choose a Quality of Earnings Provider

Because there is no required standard, providers differ more than most buyers expect. When you compare firms, ask:

  • Who performs the work, and how much of it is done by senior people?
  • Does every report include a proof of cash and a working capital analysis with a peg?
  • Is the fee fixed, and what is in the scope?
  • How much experience do they have with deals of your size and in your industry?
  • Will your lender accept the report, and will the firm talk to the lender?
  • Will they be available after closing if questions come up?

Our guide to the best quality of earnings provider for a $3 million to $5 million purchase goes through these questions in more detail.

Frequently Asked Questions

QoE stands for quality of earnings. In finance, it refers to an independent analysis of how accurate, repeatable and cash-backed a company’s reported earnings are. People also say QoE report, QoE analysis or QoE review to mean the same thing.

No. An audit gives an opinion on whether financial statements follow GAAP and is performed by a licensed CPA firm. A QoE is a consulting engagement that focuses on adjusted earnings, cash and working capital. A business does not need to have been audited to have a QoE.

It is not required in every deal, but it is strongly recommended whenever the price depends on earnings. Some lenders require one, and SBA 7(a) acquisitions with a purchase price of $3 million or more now need one under the updated SBA rules.

Most take 2 to 4 weeks. The timeline depends on how fast the seller provides records, how clean the books are and how complex the business is.

The fee depends on the size and complexity of the business, the condition of its records and the scope of work. At Midwest CPA, QoE work is done for a fixed fee. Our article on the cost of a quality of earnings report lists the factors that affect it.

Yes. A sell-side QoE lets the seller test the numbers before going to market, support legitimate add-backs and prepare for buyer questions. See our article on sell-side quality of earnings.

No. The quality of earnings ratio is a single financial measure, commonly operating cash flow divided by net income, that shows how much of reported profit is backed by cash. A QoE report is a full engagement, and a cash conversion check is only one of the tests inside it.

How Midwest CPA Can Help

Midwest CPA is a CPA firm that focuses on business acquisitions. We have completed more than 350 quality of earnings reports on transactions with a combined value of over $1 billion, including more than 90 deals in the last 12 months. Every QoE we deliver includes a proof of cash and a net working capital analysis with a peg, and we do not perform audits or tax due diligence. Learn more about our quality of earnings analysis service, or use our due diligence checklist to prepare for your next deal.

If you are thinking about buying a business, we are glad to talk through your deal before you commit.

Sources

Related Resources

Disclaimer

The content contained in this blog post is intended for general informational purposes only and is not meant to constitute legal, tax, accounting, or investment advice. You should consult a qualified legal or tax professional regarding your specific situation.

Scroll to Top

Contact

Connect

Free checklist

Due Diligence Checklist for Buying a Business

The financial items to request and review before you close, so you can buy with confidence.

  • Confirm earnings and financial health
  • Find hidden risks, debts and liabilities
  • Test the asking price against true value

From Midwest CPA, a licensed CPA firm with 350+ deals completed since 2022.

Where should we send it?

We’ll email the checklist to your inbox.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.